New variations of the comic began popping up shortly after the original was uploaded, particularly on Tumblr and Reddit. For example, on December 9th, 2013, Redditor /u/QuillJS uploaded a version of the comic replacing the peach with a burger to /r/fffffffuuuuuuuuuuuu (shown below, left). In May 2015, Tumblr user heyyaesviernes posted a series of increasingly verbose Peach Time memes, garnering over 39,000 notes in five years. On October 1st, 2015, Tumblr user wingedcatgirl-archive posted a version of the comic replacing the peach with a pumpkin (shown below, right).
Tumblr users continued to make new variations of the meme over the course of the decade, often finding mild success on the platform. On September 26th, 2018, Tumblr user sheepytina uploaded a variation of the meme referencing Super Mario Bros. character Princess Peach, garnering over 21,000 notes in two years (shown below).
On January 16th, 2019, Tumblr user ventsnstuff uploaded a version of the meme reminding users to take any medication they may require, garnering over 900 notes in two years (shown below, left). On June 1st, 2019, Tumblr user turtletoria posted an LGBTQ+ pride themed version of the comic, garnering over 1,700 upvotes in a year (shown below, right).